Vinegar Pickles vs. Indian Spice Pickles: What's the Difference?

Pickled vegetables are a staple condiment and side dish in cuisines around the world. While the basic concept of pickling - preserving food in an acidic solution - is the same, the methods and flavors can vary greatly depending on the culinary tradition. Two of the most well-known pickle types are vinegar pickles and Indian spice pickles, and there are some key differences between the two.

Vinegar Pickles Vinegar pickles, also known as quick pickles or refrigerator pickles, are the most common type of pickle found in Western cuisines. They are made by submerging vegetables, fruits, or other foods in a simple brine of vinegar, salt, and sometimes sugar.

The acidity from the vinegar is the primary preservative in vinegar pickles, quickly halting the growth of harmful bacteria and enzymes that cause spoilage. Common vinegars used include white vinegar, apple cider vinegar, or red wine vinegar.

Flavor-wise, vinegar pickles tend to be quite tangy and sour, with the vinegar flavor being the dominant taste. They often have a clean, crisp texture and can range from mildly flavored to quite intensely sour. Popular examples include dill pickles, bread and butter pickles, and pickled onions.

Indian Spice Pickles In contrast, Indian spice pickles (known as achaar) are made using an oil-based brine infused with a complex blend of spices, herbs, and seasonings. The acidic element usually comes from ingredients like lemon juice, tamarind, or mango powder rather than vinegar.

The spice blend is what gives Indian pickles their signature bold, pungent flavors. Common spices include mustard seeds, cumin, fenugreek, chili peppers, and asafetida. The oil, often mustard or sesame oil, helps extract and carry the flavors of these spices.

Indian pickles can be quite fiery from the chilies, but the heat is balanced by layers of other flavors like sour, savory, and sometimes sweet notes. The texture is usually softer and more saturated with oil compared to vinegar pickles.

Some well-known Indian pickle varieties include mango pickle, lime pickle, and mixed vegetable pickle (known as mixed achaar).

The Key Differences In summary, the main differences between vinegar pickles and Indian spice pickles are:

  • Preservative: Vinegar vs. spiced oil
  • Dominant flavors: Tangy/sour vs. complex spices
  • Texture: Crisp vs. soft/oily
  • Common examples: Dill, bread & butter, onion vs. mango, lime, mixed veg

Both types of pickles can add a delicious punch of flavor to a variety of dishes. But the distinct taste profiles mean they work best in different culinary contexts - vinegar pickles shine in Western dishes, while Indian spice pickles are a perfect complement to South Asian cuisine.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.